If there is any truth in what is argued, then this argument itself can be considered to be a display of intellectual hipster meta-contrarianism. Furthermore, any balanced position/argument could be indicted as 'intellectual hipster meta-contrarianism'. In that case, this article adds absolutely nothing to your understanding of the world and people's behavior. It's just pretending to show some deep insight, by knitting together platitudes about peoples' behavior in a seemingly novel and intellectual way.
Or, to be somewhat less of an 'intellectual hipster meta-...-meta-contrarian' (ain't I (un)cool?): what is argued is way to strong and way to broadly applied. 'Lesswrong' usually worries about the practicality of matters and this, on the one hand, just not an important factor, and on the other hand, irrelevant, even if it was, because you still have to counter the actual arguments that are made. If being an 'intellectual hipster meta-contrarian' means taking a balanced position, for instance on
- KKK-style racist / politically correct liberal / "but there are scientifically proven
genetic differences"
- misogyny / women's rights movement / men's rights movement
- conservative / liberal / libertarian
- don't care about Africa / give aid to Africa / don't give aid to Africa
then, by God, let's have more 'intellectual hipster meta-contrarian's. If it doesn't in practice, for most 'intellectual hipster meta-contrarian's mean 'taking a balanced position', for whatever reason, then I think it's just an empty denomination.
Or, to be somewhat less of an 'intellectual hipster meta-...-meta-contrarian' (ain't I (un)cool?): what is argued is way to strong and way to broadly applied. 'Lesswrong' usually worries about the practicality of matters and this, on the one hand, just not an important factor, and on the other hand, irrelevant, even if it was, because you still have to counter the actual arguments that are made. If being an 'intellectual hipster meta-contrarian' means taking a balanced position, for instance on
then, by God, let's have more 'intellectual hipster meta-contrarian's. If it doesn't in practice, for most 'intellectual hipster meta-contrarian's mean 'taking a balanced position', for whatever reason, then I think it's just an empty denomination.