Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Separately, when you look at successful tech companies, it seems that dividends are an approach used by cash rich operations to distribute excess earnings — in fact, the most successful, cash rich tech company in the world, Apple, hasn’t issued a dividend and they have more than $75B in cash!

The fact that companies can get away with something like this is absolutely ludicrous. It illustrates just how far the stock market has gone from its original purpose.

Back before companies had the ability to sweet-talk investors with bulging pockets, companies wanting capital had to raise it the good-old-fashioned-way: IPO. IPO used to have the ability to allow a company to access as much capital as it would reasonably need to grow. But with the preponderance of heavily privatized companies milking both the private AND the public side of the investment machine, the value-creating just cannot be accounted for properly. Something in the gears here needs to be tweaked.

A company like Apple with $75B cash (if that's true) should have a legal and an ethical obligation to pay out dividends to its shareholders. Tight-fisting cash doesn't do anything to the wealth-creating mechanism in our capitalistic society.



Ah, but if they paid it out in dividends, it would be taxed!

Apple's cash hoard is functioning as a giant insurance policy against Apple's stock price, which if you buy and hold, never gets taxed.


Also a lot of Apples "cash" is overseas, where it would lose a lot to be bought back in.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: