Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> The biggest issue you aren't considering is that the biggest advantage of a gun is that you just have to have it. Power isn't shooting someone accurately - it's bringing a gun to a knife fight. Having a knife means you have to close to the target to engage - having a gun means I can stand back and project power.

Brandishing isn't something a gun is for, i'm sorry. It's an extraordinarily bad idea to use a gun as a tool for threatening a would-be attacker for both your health, and your legal well-being.[0][1]

> Furthermore, every firearm made in America in the last century has been certified as drop safe.

Single action revolvers have absolutely no safety other than the geometry of their design to prevent accidental discharge and (sometimes) an external safety. Here is the first list of them I found for sale readily on google.[2]

Here's a list of de-certified firearms [3], I'd like you to notice the amount of modern guns de-certified just last year for sale for being deemed unsafe (for these varied reasons[4]). I apologize for the CA-centric data, it was just easiest to find.

Competition shooting pistols often have absolutely no safety devices at all, and plenty are manufactured within the United States.

Many pistols are heirloomed or sold privately, those pistols are not required by law to conform to any safety standards, and can be sold indefinitely. Their high value nature aids the used gun economy, another incentive to have a gun sans modern safeties.[4 :relics and curios/heirloom footnote]

> Poppy cock. Modern firearms don't just go off [0].

Well, here's a blog post with enthusiasts arguing over that.[5] I have a few guns that were left to me by the deceased, but I am by no means an enthusiast.

Here's a blog-post that used wording similar to yours regarding the last century, but he describes drop-safe guns as 'a vast majority' rather than 'every', further explaining about which (modern) guns are never drop-safe.[6]

Now, let me say that I sincerely hope that someone who is going to take the effort to arm their house with a gun will do the homework to figure out a safe firearm to do so with, and with the proper training; but we don't live in that world. People will grab something convenient, just like anything else in life. That means cheap, old, or a knock-off.

[0]: http://www.secondcalldefense.org/self-defense-news/why-brand...

[1]: http://volokh.com/2010/02/12/if-you-brandish-a-gun-in-self-d...

[2]: http://www.gandermountain.com/Guns/New-Guns/New-Handguns/Sin...

[3]: http://oag.ca.gov/sites/oag.ca.gov/files/pdfs/firearms/remov...

[4]: http://smartgunlaws.org/design-safety-standards-for-handguns...

[5]: http://www.commongunsense.com/2010/09/can-guns-go-off-withou...

[6]: http://monderno.com/training/accidental-discharge-question/



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: